[Burichan]  [Futaba]  [Halloween]  [Fuhrerchan]  [Gurochan]  [Harrischan]  [Kusaba]  [Photon]  -  [WT]  [Home] [Manage]

[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts]
Posting mode: Reply
Links: [Wiki] [Pastebin] [Karlsland.net imageboard] Ventrilo: [Texas2.MaxFrag.net 4126 Pass: mikan] Support: [Github] [Email] Change log: [Github]
Name
Email
Subject   (reply to 591)
Message
Captcha
File
Embed   Help
Password  (for post and file deletion)
  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG, WEBM
  • Maximum file size allowed is 4966 KB.
  • Images greater than 200x200 pixels will be thumbnailed.
  • Currently 3171 unique user posts. View catalog

File 131304436258.png - (1.45MB , 1610x970 , 17797841 (いちご - 大空の魔女達).png )
591 No. 591 ID: 4d2005
Alright, I am going to throw down the gauntlet. My witches vs your witches. Your witches vs their witches. Who truly is best? Obviously depends on one's definition of best, so I'll narrow it down to best in category.

Most powerful?

Best aerial fighter?

Most moe?

Best leader?

Most mature?

Best friend?

Most cool?

Best oppai?

Most perfect?

Best speciality?

Most reliable?

Best familiar?

Most sex appeal?

Best overall?

Give me your OPINIONS
Expand all images
>> No. 694 ID: b82920
File 131407862917.jpg - (576.50KB , 1920x1200 , perrine.jpg )
694
>Most powerful?
Perrine
>Best aerial fighter?
Perrine
>Most moe?
Perrine
?Best leader?
Perrine
>Most mature?
Perrine
>Best friend?
Perrine
>Most cool?
Perrine
>Best oppai?
Perrine
>Most perfect?
Perrine Perrine Perrine Perrine PERRINE
>Best speciality?
Perrine
>Most reliable?
Perrine
>Best familiar?
Perrine
>Most sex appeal?
Perrine
>Best overall?
Perrine
>> No. 695 ID: 561bbd
File 131412632326.jpg - (33.42KB , 500x371 , sarcasm.jpg )
695
>>694

>Frying-Pan Perrine for Best oppai
>> No. 696 ID: f03502
File 13141811497.jpg - (185.37KB , 1155x1155 , Perrine_gets_her_glasses_stolen.jpg )
696
It's pretty hard to do this when there's very few of the witches properly shown. But I'll try

>Most powerful?
Ground: Charlotte (Afrika), Air: Kanno Naoe

>Best aerial fighter?
Hanna-Justina Marseille

>Most moe?
Francie Gerard

>Best leader?
Gundula Rall

>Most mature?
Minna-Dietlinde Wilcke

>Best friend?
I don't have one ;_;

>Most cool?
Dominica S. Gentile

>Best oppai?
Charlotte E. Yeager

>Most perfect?
Perrine (So I won't get banned)

>Best speciality?
Angela Salas Larrazabal (Retcameo)

>Most reliable?
Nikka Edvardine Katajainen

>Best familiar?
Aleksandra I. Pokryshkin (It's a goddamn Polar Bear)

>Most sex appeal?
Federica N. Doglio (Those calenders)

>Best overall?
Eila Ilmatar Juutilainen (attitude, abilities, and voice)

There, Perfect and best pic
>> No. 699 ID: c890e9
File 13142144716.png - (179.37KB , 451x438 , trash1.png )
699
>>696

> So I won't get banned

The fuck?
>> No. 700 ID: 79cdf8
>>699
Nobody's going to get banned for something like that.
>> No. 705 ID: f03502
>>699
>>700
It was just a joke, sorry.
>> No. 817 ID: e343e5
bump...looked like fun

>Most powerful?
Gertrud Barkhorn

>Best aerial fighter?
Erica Hartmann

>Most moe?
Inagaki Mami

>Best leader?
I think they're all good in their own way, IMO

>Most mature?
Edytha Rossman

>Best friend?
Sakamoto Mio (BEST LAUGH EVER)

>Most cool?
Hanna U. Rudel (the nose scar adds extra coolness)

>Best oppai?
Katharine O'Hare

>Most perfect?
Adolfine Galland

>Best speciality?
Nikka Edvardine Katajainen (she's like the wolverine of her universe with her hyper regeneration)

>Most reliable?
Hanna Wind

>Best familiar?
Aleksandra I. Pokryshkin (those...ears...)

>Most sex appeal?
Federica N. Doglio (DAT CALENDAR)

>Best overall?
undecided here...
>> No. 4995 ID: 039e00
File 135311231682.png - (208.42KB , 300x450 , 579837-charlotte_e__yeager__profile_portrait__larg.png )
4995
>Most powerful?
Charlotte
>Best aerial fighter?
Charlotte
>Most moe?
Charlotte
>Best leader?
Charlotte
>Most mature?
Charlotte
>Best friend?
Lynette
>Most cool?
Charlotte
>Best oppai?
Charlotte
>Most perfect?
Charlotte
>Best speciality?
Kanno Naoe
>Most reliable?
Charlotte
>Best familiar?
Charlotte
>Most sex appeal?
Charlotte
>Best overall?
Charlotte

I tried answering without sounding bias.
I think I succeeded.
>> No. 4996 ID: 1ba170
File 135311422634.jpg - (278.21KB , 600x600 , 8c9f0499399042324351e08ee56bb20b.jpg )
4996
Every category, Eila.

OBVIOUSLY.
>> No. 4997 ID: 901cce
File 135312359387.jpg - (257.70KB , 720x856 , 2126807.jpg )
4997
>Most powerful?
Yoshika
>Best aerial fighter?
Hartmann or Marseille
>Most moe?
Yoshika
>Best leader?
Not sure on this one
>Most mature?
Beurling
>Best friend?
Eila
>Most cool?
Beurling
>Best oppai?
Katherine
>Most perfect?
Yoshika
>Best speciality?
Eila, seeing the future
>Most reliable?
Barkhorn
>Best familiar?
Erica & Ursula
>Most sex appeal?
Too hard to decide
>Best overall?
Yoshika or Beurling
>> No. 4998 ID: e76c3b
Most powerful? Barkhorn

Best aerial fighter? Hartman or Marsaille

Most moe? Lynette

Best leader? Major Sakamoto

Most mature? Barkhorn

Best friend? Yoshika

Most cool? Barkhorn, Charlotte, or Perrine

Best oppai? Charlotte, obviously.

Most perfect? Barkhorn

Best speciality? Perrine

Most reliable? Barkhorn

Best familiar? Minna

Most sex appeal? Charlotte

Best overall? Charlotte (As an Ameri-*cough* Liberion. Otherwise, Barkhorn)
>> No. 5001 ID: a2f61b
File 135316169943.jpg - (304.60KB , 761x571 , c01d92d8dda72577a0cee0ff3276a1e7.jpg )
5001
Most powerful? Sakamoto-saaaan

Best aerial fighter? Marseille

Most moe? Inagaki Mami

Best leader? Anabuki Tomoko (in combat, that is)

Most mature? Minna

Best friend? Eila

Most cool? Marseille. She defines cool.

Best oppai? Barkhorn (chin-up scene, Season 2 Ep 4 for reference)

Most perfect? Eila~

Best specialty? Kanno Naoe

Most reliable? Barkhorn

Best familiar? Not sure. I like floppy ears.

Most sex appeal? Barkhorn, rrRRRrr

Best overall? Eila
>> No. 5020 ID: 584678
File 135336006888.png - (389.02KB , 587x944 , 3baf33d505eb2780b5c28426f56cc45a.png )
5020
Most powerful?
I'd probably have to say Trude.
Best aerial fighter?
Tomoko
Most moe?
Pfft, Sanya
Best leader?
Tomoko
Most mature?
Hattori Shizuka
Best friend?
Katherine O'Hare
Most cool?
Old Eila
Best oppai?
Shaalii Yeager
Most perfect?
Nice joke. They're all perfectly perfect
Best speciality?
Haruka's Miso Soup
Most reliable?
Yoshika fucking Mary-Sue bitch
Best familiar?
Woozels
Most sex appeal?
Haruka's Miso Soup
Best overall?
Neauroi Witch
>> No. 5023 ID: 89d2bd
File 135337199864.jpg - (741.53KB , 900x1416 , 30713605.jpg )
5023
Most powerful?
Yoshika - biggest shield ever, Miyafuji family ability, destroying two hives, etc...

Best aerial fighter?
Marseille - only because Neuroi in Africa is more formidable than on Eastern front

Most moe?
Helma - of course

Best leader?
Rall - managing the Break Witches in and out of combat

Most mature?
Keiko - not only of actual age, but also for her vast experiences

Best friend?
Shirley - definitely a bro

Most cool?
Beurling - Gurkha knife, motorcycle, cigarettes... what isn't cool about her?

Best oppai?
Katherine or Shirley - tied for the size

Most perfect?
Adolfine - over-a-hundred ace, long time veteran, Karlsland General of Witches, and a jet striker test pilot.

Best specialty?
Ayaka - being able to express quantitative characteristic in specific values

Most reliable?
Major Miles - Always at the front when you need her

Best familiar?
Kümmel - A Lion

Most sex appeal?
Shirley - pic related

Best overall?
Rall
>> No. 5028 ID: 09af1c
File 135343831592.jpg - (256.54KB , 1600x1050 , Perrine_H__Clostermann_full_947141.jpg )
5028
>Most powerful?
Kanno
>Best aerial fighter?
Erica Hartmann
>Most moe?
Wilma Bishop
>Best leader?
Mio
>Most mature?
Minna
>Best friend?
Lucchini!
>Most cool?
Marseille
>Best oppai?
Shirley-san
>Most perfect?
Perrine, Perrine, Perrine
>Best speciality?
Eila
>Most reliable?
Miyafuji
>Best familiar?
Eila
>Most sex appeal?
Shirley
>Best overall?
Perrine
>> No. 5030 ID: 1ba170
>>5023
>Most powerful?
>Yoshika - biggest shield ever, Miyafuji family ability, destroying two hives, etc...

See this shit? this is the result of the shitty direction SW franchise has taken. Casual fans actually think Yoshika is the most powerful witch. Can't blame them, it certainly looks like that when you watch the show circa last half of S2 - the movie.

But she's not supposed to be even the strongest _Fuso_ witch! She's not based on a famous ace, she's based on a complete nobody!
>> No. 5036 ID: 89d2bd
>>5030
Most powerful=/=strongest.
Yoshika certainly doesn't have advanced piloting skills like other veterans, but her magic output is by far the largest of any witches shown.
She can even deploy a magic circle larger than IJN Yamato (about 840ft), AND overload A6M's safety limiter.
Heck, her magical power is the only reason she's in 501st.

By the way, she is actually based on Kaneyoshi Mutoh who fought against a dozen F6Fs by himself in a prototype N1K2, took down a third of them, and came back alive.
So yeah, she's based on a famous ace pilot.
>> No. 5039 ID: 7932ac
>>5036
Never knew her cheapness is based on this Muto guy's prowess.

I assume Muto had a Wingman against those multiple Hellcats right? I guess adapting Muto into Yoshika didn't went well and somehow made her look like an Overpowered character.
>> No. 5041 ID: 89d2bd
File 135354532367.jpg - (35.82KB , 480x360 , Shiden-Kai_Mutoh.jpg )
5041
>>5039
>Muto had a Wingman
Nope
At the time, Mutoh was separated from the rest of his squadron (consisting of A6Ms and few more prototype N1K2s) which was engaged with another squadron elsewhere
He engaged against the Hellcats all alone
Oh, did I mention his N1K2 was painted bright orange because it was a prototype?

Saburo Sakai (who Mio is based on) was a close friend of Mutoh and they flew together often as well
Sakai commented that Mutoh had real talent for flying while he himself was only good because of extreme cautiousness.

In June 1945, Mutoh was reassigned from Yokosuka Naval Air Group where he was a test pilot to 343rd Naval Air Group to replace injured Sakai in combat missions.
He was personally asked by Minoru Genda, commander of 343rd NAG to protect Naoshi Kanno (who Naoe is based on) at all cost.
Mutoh replied that "Kanno won't die as long as I'm there"
He and Kanno with 19 other squadron members engaged American carrier air group of over 200 aircrafts on July 24, 1945 (by the way, this is the date the finale of second season first aired).
Mutoh covered Kanno throughout the battle, successfully saving him on multiple occasions.
Kanno made it back to base alive, but Mutoh was never found.
Sakai who survived the war, considered that Mutoh died in his place and regretted that he wasn't the one to die even decades after the war ended.

So I'm okay if not kind of glad that Yoshika is a bit overpowered.
Things like what happened in real life won't be happening to them.
I do agree that Yoshika's strength could have been presented better, though.

Pic related is N1K2 recovered from bottom of the sea which is said to be the one Mutoh was flying when he went MIA.
>> No. 5046 ID: 530038
This Mutoh guy is a total badass. I totally respect Yoshika now.
>> No. 5051 ID: a4b155
>>5041
If that makes it acceptable for Yoshika to be overpowered then shouldn't Beurling be put on a similar level? He regularly flew in conditions where he was heavily outnumbered while stationed on Malta.

I can sort of appreciate that he did well to fend off so many aircraft on his own but considering similar conditions had been imposed on many other pilots during the war, it's hardly fair to cite that as justification for Yoshika's power.
>> No. 5069 ID: c48e19
Deliberately excluding the 501st here:

Most powerful? Kanno Naoe

Best aerial fighter? Hanna-Justine Marseille

Most moe? Elma Leivonen

Best leader? Wilma Bishop

Most mature? Gundana Rall

Best friend? Waltrud Krupinski

Most cool? Aurora Juutilainen

Best oppai? Heidemarie Schnaufer

Most perfect? Adolfine Galland

Best speciality? Nikka Katajainen

Most reliable? Elizabeth Beurling

Best familiar? Aleksandra Pokryshkin

Most sex appeal? Federica Doglio

Best overall? Anabuki Tomoko
>> No. 5077 ID: 1ba170
>>5036
>Most powerful=/=strongest.

Actually, no. Most powerful means strongest. They are synonyms.
>> No. 5078 ID: 1ba170
>>5036
>>5041

That story doesn't in any way give Yoshika a "right" to marginalize other 501st members. Each one of them is the best pilot of their own country, and each one of their RL equivalents was likely better than Yoshika's RL equivalent.
>> No. 5080 ID: 0ae88b
>>5077
You need to look at the context. Just because Yoshika has the most magical power doesn't mean she's the best ace, Hartmann and Barkhorn were the ones considered for that super elite mission with Marseille for example. In this way, she is the most powerful, but not the strongest 501st member. Her special ability is healing, which isn't meant for combat after all.
>> No. 5083 ID: 1ba170
>>5080

If you're specifically going to talk about magical power reserves, just say "witch with the most magical power". Just saying "most powerful" brings to mind DBZ style power, who-can-beat-who power. >>5023 certainly wasn't talking about the length of her mana bar when he blabbed about "destroying two hives", it was straight up destructive power.
>> No. 5085 ID: 89d2bd
File 135393681369.jpg - (168.83KB , 600x609 , 22994523_p7.jpg )
5085
It probably won't sound right coming from me, but just a reminder this is a opinion thread, not a factual comparative thread.
So please do respect other people's opinions.

>>5051
>>5078
It really doesn't make it acceptable, as I said.
I merely brought it up as "fun fact" and my PERSONAL reasoning for being okay with how Yoshika's overpowered.
And I know that I can't really compare RL counterpart to the witches, because they aren't same.
I also don't intend on stating any of the real life aces were superior to the other because there's no way to come up with concrete conclusion.
With all that said, I still think she is the most powerful witch, because of her inherent magical power.

>>5077
>>5083
what >>5080 said.
I thought destroying both hive did result from her magical capacity/output in both cases, letting striker powered by her vast magical power blow up/Shin-reppuzan.
So what I meant there is how she destroyed the hive with her magical powers.
If I was to decide who was the strongest, I certainly wouldn't have picked Yoshika.
She has powers, but no experience and very little training.
>> No. 5165 ID: 1ba170
Yoshika is a cancer killing this franchise.
>> No. 7211 ID: 54e195
>>696
>>Most reliable?
>Nikka Edvardine Katajainen
I lol'd. Thanks for bumping this, spambot. I would've never noticed that gem otherwise.
>> No. 7223 ID: a66ba8
>>694
PERRINE FOR ALL!!!! THE BEST WITCH!!!!
>> No. 7244 ID: ff3ad4
>>7223

Nobody loves Perrine, right Paulino?
>> No. 7245 ID: a66ba8
>>7244
EVEN IN THIS PAGE!!!!
I'm tired of you jokes.
Just for one moment in your life, STOP FUCKING ME.
>> No. 7247 ID: a61743
File 141343637972.png - (31.06KB , 400x400 , 1222310983969.png )
7247
>>7245

Perrine pls
[Return] [Entire Thread] [Last 50 posts]


Delete post []
Password  
Report post
Reason  


All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.